Darcy DuMont

What is the hauler proposal?

On Aug. 15, 2022, a proposal came up before the Town Council to switch from individual subscription hauling services to town-contracted hauling that would include curbside compost pick up. The proposal requires that the program be phased in, starting with 1-4 family homes and later including apartment complexes, homeowners associations and businesses. It requires a Pay As You Throw fee structure. The proposal was referred to the Town Services and Outreach Committee (TSO). 

​Who is proposing hauler reform?

The current councilor sponsors are: Jennifer Taub, Ellisha Walker, Amber Cano-Martin and Jill Brevik. The community sponsor is Zero Waste Amherst. 

​What is the current status of the proposal?

In 2024, the council unanimously voted to urge the manager to issue a Request for Proposals (RFP) to haulers to obtain cost information. After receiving a draft RFP from consultant Mimi Kaplan, TSO worked on formulating recommendations.

Most recently, the sponsors have proposed to phase in curbside compost collection. Under this proposal,  residents would be invited to participate in a program of voluntary curbside compost collection. The phase-in would give residents time to learn about curbside composting and its benefits. After the two years, the program would become part of basic curbside service included in the hauler contract(s). 

Why would Amherst want to change to a town contract?

Making the proposed changes would be better for the climate, better for our air, soil and water, and better for our pocketbooks! It would also move us toward achieving our state and local Zero Waste and Climate Action goals. 

USA Waste and Recycling has raised its rates significantly since achieving a virtual monopoly in Amherst.  A competitive bidding process resulting in a town contract would almost certainly bring down prices and would give the town the ability to implement waste reduction practices. For every day we maintain the status quo, we send at least double the amount of trash to landfills and incinerators than we would if implementing this proposal. 

How can I support the proposal?

You can support the proposal by emailing the Town Council at TownCouncil@amherstma.gov. Enter your comment on this form.

​Why would we want to require our hauler to provide a proportional Pay As You Throw fee structure?

Our current residential waste hauler charges only a $2 difference monthly between each size cart and NO difference if your collection is weekly or biweekly. There is no financial incentive to reduce waste. 

​Pay as you throw systems incentivize waste reduction and have been shown to reduce waste by 35%. In the proposed program, households would pay more or less according to pickup frequency and how many overflow bags or extra carts they need to hold their trash. If they generate more trash, they pay more. 

Does Pay As You Throw disadvantage anyone?

PAYT treats trash collection as a utility. The more trash you produce, the more you pay. Low wasters will no longer subsidize large wasters. The objective is to learn how to waste less. Large households are very unlikely to be paying a hauler more than what they are paying now for trash and recycling once the town has a contract.

​Why use one size carts and overflow bags?

We don’t know that we’ll be using one size carts and overflow bags but it is the best practice in waste reduction because people tend to notice that they are wasting and paying more when they see overflow bags.  

What we do will depend on the RFP responses and the town council vote on a bylaw. But the overflow bag issue is not a deal breaker. There are other options such as using additional same size carts rather than bags or using a combination of the two.

​​If we use overflow bags, won’t animals get into them?

Many towns now use overflow bags. Any plastic bags with food in them will attract animals, whether in carts or not. Using common sense, like diverting food from the bags, is the best bet. 

Why would we want to include curbside compostable materials collection?

Offering this service is expected to reduce our waste stream by an additional 40%. Each household would get a container for compost, starting with a voluntary program. Almost half of what previously went in your trash would go in your compost bin. By pairing universal compost collection with a meaningful pay-as-you-throw system, we can reduce trash by up to 75%.

What would be included in the compostable materials?

“Compostable materials” include organic material — food scraps, food-soiled paper, compostable containers, clean wood and plants and possibly yard waste.

​I already put my food scraps in a backyard compost pile. 

There are many items that backyard composters don’t add to their compost, including meat, eggs, bread and other food that attracts animals. Also, paper products and compostable containers don’t break down in backyard compost because the temperature doesn’t get high enough. There will be plenty to put in your compost bin even if you continue to backyard compost. 

What would this change cost residents?

We won’t find out the amount of the basic fee until the town awards a contract to a bidder. But residents in other towns with contracts pay on average half of what residents with subscriptions pay for trash and recycling services. It will also depend on how much trash you put out. 

Can I continue using the transfer station for trash and recycling?

Sponsors’ most recent proposal allows transfer station users to opt out of the hauler contract. 

What groups have endorsed the general proposal?

Fourteen town, regional and statewide groups have endorsed the main concepts of the proposal.

Do we know current prices for USA Recycling and Waste services?

The average cost per household of USA hauling (in 2023) was $550/year. The additional cost for picking up compost curbside by USA is $15/month. Their “concierge” service, picking up from your door, is $1,000/year with no exemptions.

See the Zero Waste Amherst FAQ page for more questions and answers.

Darcy DuMont is a former town councilor and sponsor of the legislation creating the Amherst Energy and Climate Action Committee. She is a founding member of Zero Waste Amherst, Local Energy Advocates of Western MA, and a non-voting member of Valley Green Energy Working Group. She can be contacted at dumint140@gmail.com.